Sacramento’s Suburban Experiment

Since World War II, Sacramento has been running its most expensive experiment: designing the entire city around the private automobile, favoring tax-unproductive land uses, and building public infrastructure without budgeting for its long-term upkeep.

What you’ll see: streetcar lines replaced by freeways, jaywalking banned, parking mandates imposed, single-family zoning locked in, and wave after wave of suburban subdivisions approved across the county from 1900 through 2024 — then the costs. Sacramento now carries a $419 million unfunded pavement repair backlog, holds the highest per-capita car-crash fatality rate of any large California city, and has an income-normalized rental market more expensive than New York City.

Strong Towns argues the post-war suburban development pattern was a massive bet that did not pay off, and that we need to re-learn how cities were traditionally built. Help us end the suburban experiment in Sacramento by joining Strong SacTown, a local conversation in the national movement. We have in-person events and working group meetings every month, hundreds of members across every council district, and we’re looking forward to growing in 2026!

Sources

Part 1: The Experiment

  • Filed Subdivision Maps, Sacramento County. Sacramento County Open Data, 2025. — Primary geographic dataset for the animation: all approved subdivision applications since 1900.
  • K Street historic photographs, used to establish roughly when Sacramento streets were paved with asphalt. Center for Sacramento History.
  • Ordinance Number 304. City of Sacramento, 1926. (archived) — Jaywalking prohibited.
  • Sacramento’s Streetcars. William Burg, Arcadia Publishing, 2006 (p. 208). — Documents the 1946 dismantling of Sacramento’s streetcar network; system maps and route descriptions.
  • Ordinance Number 1483. City of Sacramento, 1950 (p. 7). (archived) — Established minimum parking requirements, mandating car parking to be built for nearly all buildings.
  • Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956. Wikipedia. — Federal funding that financed Sacramento’s freeway construction.
  • Historic aerial imagery, 1947–1973. USGS Earth Explorer. — Used to determine when each freeway segment in Sacramento County was constructed.
  • Ordinance Number 1963. City of Sacramento, 1962. (archived) — Establishment of R-1 single-family zoning, locking in low-density suburban development.
  • Efficient Street To Drivers, Noisy Peril To Residents. The Sacramento Bee, October 22, 1978 (p. 34). — Documents the human cost of downtown one-way street conversions: residents describe noise and danger, small business owners report declining sales, while city planners call the conversions a success for suburban commuters.

Part 2: The Results

Audio

Tools Used

The following tools were instrumental in the creation of this animation:

  • QGIS – for preparing geospatial data for Blender’s consumption.
  • Krita – overlay graphics.
  • Blender – animation/compositing.
  • Ardour – soundtrack, and for composing the piano track at the end.

Posted in:

Tags: